Jump to content

MORANE SAULNIER A1 1/3 scale


Steve Fox
 Share

Recommended Posts

Oh joy

The winds are back in force. I was hoping for  a quick go with the Bixler this morning. 

No. I think most of the country copping it. I tried going out to workshop but it was so loud I couldn't hear myself thinking. 

The power off now so must be some lines down.

Maybe tomorrow. 

I have been thinking about the fuel tank height in relation to the gas engine. Where should the position/ height be of the tank.20231002_165944.thumb.jpg.9101d20b72c33778f4fe9656713afe72.jpg  My first petrol engine so all new to me.

Are there any good articles and or advice about.

Cheers Steve NZ 

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Better weather 

Hello folks,well the weather is slowly improving,  we made 23 c spring day yesterday which was very pleasant.

20231007_143534.thumb.jpg.9e43ceaa1f43c4cf7b7c4762139648ea.jpg
 

20231007_142624.thumb.jpg.29a477cea4969d2b842e1fcfaef2167b.jpg

The Morane build is moving ahead  quietly.
The main focus has been about position the rudder and elevator servos, which I think I have sorted now.by placing them further forward by about 10 cm (4 inches) from my original position under the cockpit area.
So now positioned under the fuel tank  area behind the firewall.

20231007_170308.thumb.jpg.a60b23f580ba2e7f65c4b0e10c84e151.jpg
20231007_135319.thumb.jpg.46bda6a3681a5806c0f781dd5fdebd34.jpg

20231007_170424.thumb.jpg.5298bd8a66e5b468ae56855a9c46efcc.jpg

Access to the servos will be from underneath via the belly pan.
The full size Morane conveniently had an access hatch there so I have done the same.

20231002_153836.thumb.jpg.d8fda14b00709eff39e72936a742c66b.jpg
The setup for the rudder and elevator will be push pull at this stage. I had a go at fiberglassing the belly pan and the new hatch yesterday and it seems to have been a reasonable result.

Cheers Steve NZ 

20231008_144743.thumb.jpg.e3ab8a890ce74b35d6f3a2294943d430.jpg

20231007_172459.thumb.jpg.a80fd5baa4064436ebf3535ad3365a63.jpg

20231007_130926.jpg

Edited by Steve Fox
Add pictures
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Steve Fox said:

The setup for the rudder and elevator will be push pull at this stage.

Is there not space to add a bellcrank under the pilot seat and convert your pushrod to pull-pull? Pull-pull makes for a far more accurate and slop free method of empennage control besides looking better (IMHO) on this genre of aircraft.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, FlyinFlynn said:

Is there not space to add a bellcrank under the pilot seat and convert your pushrod to pull-pull? Pull-pull makes for a far more accurate and slop free method of empennage control besides looking better (IMHO) on this genre of aircraft.

Yes , funny 

I have been having a chance of heart about the pull pull, thanks for your thoughts. I will change over.

Cheers Steve NZ 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Steve. 

 

On my Morane, I used 3 large Hitec double output arms as bellcranks, ball raced them and mounted in a beech bearer across the fus located under the seat. Pull pull cables attached to each elevator half and the other for the rudder. Make sure the cables at the bellcrank end is the same width as at the control surface horns.  I then used carbon pushrods from the front mounted servos to the  bell cranks.  You can see the pushrods in the previous photo of the cockpit on mine. 

 

 

I successfully used this method on my first Morane as well.

 

Shaun 

Edited by 2.4g Shaun
Typo
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Hello all. 

Sorry I have been absent for a while, everything got very busy and I came to a complete standstill on the build. Back onto it again now and good progress has been made. 

The two wings are built although plenty of tidying up to do.

20231124_184441.thumb.jpg.0b5d66dfa22d9df4e2e0075e42804b2d.jpg20231222_124513.thumb.jpg.d5147ff4ef6c43aa1b1a5a5d8432de60.jpg

I hope you are all enjoying a nice Xmas break 

Cheers Steve NZ

 

1/3rd scale seat 

20231222_124316.thumb.jpg.78fea5953d677801afb03b24574c5691.jpg

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Watching this build with interest , I've recently purchased the seagull version which looks good so far . 

From previous comments did i see a recommendation for Aileron differential , also assuming a bit of rudder mix will help in the turns ?

 

 

thanks

Andy 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
On 03/01/2024 at 21:51, ARC said:

Watching this build with interest , I've recently purchased the seagull version which looks good so far . 

From previous comments did i see a recommendation for Aileron differential , also assuming a bit of rudder mix will help in the turns ?

Thanks

Andy 

Hi there Andy, yes I believe that you are correct in aileron differential and rudder mix.My 1/4 scale Fokker D.VII needs plenty of rudder in the turns, so I somehow expect the same..cheers Steve 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi folks, well some progress, but not much.

I have been reading up on how to use Koverall from SIG. This is my first attempt at using it as a covering. 

20240117_060807.thumb.jpg.7d1ae48c415f0472814c8baeee3d1bf3.jpg

I have been looking for the SIG "Stix it" adhesive in our model shops but it doesn't seem to be available here in NZ. 

So have been looking for alternatives to tack the cloth on to the air frame. 

Interesting comments on forums, such as hairspray, pva glue and dope ,mod pod as a option. 

So ended up experimenting with these ideas as I imagine a good number of folks have in the past.

20240117_060637.thumb.jpg.307c905ea7b86eab9ddd90b20c3499fd.jpg

Turns out that the Mod podge was the best at tacking the fabric onto the Balsa.

I tried a watered down podge first, let dry sanded and applied a further watered down coat After allowing it to dry, I used my covering iron to tack the fabric on.  It was ok, but not that strong a bond 

20240118_194611.thumb.jpg.af2e71665f9b73ddad60dc7991e864d7.jpg20240118_194709.thumb.jpg.4bbfe8991b3001d7b213cf8afd41e1b7.jpg

Next I tried full strength podge, allowed todry ,sanded and then applied a watered down  podge. The result was much better with a stronger tack!! So I will use this method. 

20240118_195503.thumb.jpg.06232c2f20d8bd41eef1a082e39ede15.jpg

 

The other thing I have been up to is fixing up my old HK SE5a plane which I completely destroyed months ago.after shredding through our Hazel nut tree.

I thought I had stalled it in the turn to land, but later I found the aileron clevis had fatigued and broke off at the crucial moment. 

I was going to bin it but months later I decided to re build it after realizing I didn't want to part with it.

20240118_200049.thumb.jpg.97cb8706f51a7a787b23b25fce9a4d73.jpg

I think its about 12 years old. Did anyone get one of these when they were on the HK site years ago  

20240118_200102.thumb.jpg.e82795ba45408102eaa847a97534345d.jpg

 

Cheers Steve NZ 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

When using Koverall I dope the structure and then use a medium cyno to stick the covering around the edges only, rubbing with a finger to ensure it is well glued. Small areas at a time. The cyno is used in small amounts and helps giving a nice edge when cutting the covering, no frayed edges. Using a good cream on the hands before doing this protects the skin, some use just the finger from a latex glove. Once finished you then dope the covering which adheres it to the structure( shrink first) Koverall does take quite a few coates of dope to fill the weave especially on the shetted areas. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Chris Freeman 3 said:

When using Koverall I dope the structure and then use a medium cyno to stick the covering around the edges only, rubbing with a finger to ensure it is well glued. Small areas at a time. The cyno is used in small amounts and helps giving a nice edge when cutting the covering, no frayed edges. Using a good cream on the hands before doing this protects the skin, some use just the finger from a latex glove. Once finished you then dope the covering which adheres it to the structure( shrink first) Koverall does take quite a few coates of dope to fill the weave especially on the shetted areas. 

Hi, thanks for the great tips cheers Steve 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another option would be to see what the full size aircraft guys are using as the fabric is also initially glued to the structure. Some home builders use normal contact adhesive and the iron the covering on. Stits and Stewart systems also make covering adhesive. The Stits product is a old product that still uses MEK  which comes with a health risk. The Stewart system is water based and is quite new on the market. One of my mates is busy covering a 40% Pitts at the moment and used both glues and confirmed both work very well.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi all

Well I am having an interesting time with the Koverall, not having worked with it before is producing a wide Learning experience. 

Understanding the strength of the dope have given me a few issues   My first attempt at covering the rudder broke a joint at a weak point which I was going to address prior to covering, but I forgot to do it.

I made a slit with the Drexel and installed a thin ply insert to strengthen it with additional epoxy glue 

20240122_162552.thumb.jpg.1a555f665c261e776398469e121dbc3e.jpg

 

Moreover the rudder became slightly warped much to my dismay. Not badly and went back into the correct shape once I had removed the Koverall  

Second attempt was looking very promising and I was rather pleased with my efforts. But again I noticed the rudder had warped slightly and it wasn't lining up with the tail plane. 

The strong dope is deceiving me, I wonder if I can use thiners to weaken it at all??.

So third attempt tomorrow, hopefully I will be successful .

Cheers Steve NZ 

20240124_110257.jpg

20240124_110419.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very pleased with myself,  after 3 attempts at the Koverall and think I have it worked out how to manage the dope etc .

If you look at the rudder you can see I added some balsa stick to aid the ply insert to stop the warp I was experiencing. 

 

20240125_175642.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Hi all

Well the covering of the tail feathers is complete and overall happy with it results. 

It had taken some time to do as I went very cautiously with the whole process. I certainly feel more comfortable at tackling the fuselage now. I did a sample piece of Koverall to see how paint adheres to the fabric.I used a Rustolum undercoat which went on well and appears very flexible to the surface without a hint of cracking or chipping. Then I applied some acrylic paint which had the same results. Not having a petrol engine before, I am wondering about how fuel proof this acrylic plant would be??

My next problem or issue is that once I soldered the undercarriage, I didn't notice that the left hand a little out of square giving it a toe in aspect which a little annoying, more so that I did not notice as I was working on it. 

It will require a slight bend back. My plan is to give it to my son and he can sort it out at his workshop where he has the equipment to make good.

Hot weather here at present so a bit hot at times to work in the garage, mostly early evening is ok

Cheers Steve NZ 

 

 

20240202_204903.jpg

20240204_200847.jpg

20240204_201819.jpg

20240204_201750.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

        With models of this size I recon it is good to have suspension in the way of the full size to dampen bounce on landing.

Axle can travel up and back some in a loop on the rear leg. Bungee cord around a pin on front leg holds axle down in place but stretch's to absorb shock on landing.

336563394_BristolUC.thumb.JPG.a3e654a66a064838c8ab6f5aa1f892a7.JPG

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, J D 8 said:

        With models of this size I recon it is good to have suspension in the way of the full size to dampen bounce on landing.

Axle can travel up and back some in a loop on the rear leg. Bungee cord around a pin on front leg holds axle down in place but stretch's to absorb shock on landing.

336563394_BristolUC.thumb.JPG.a3e654a66a064838c8ab6f5aa1f892a7.JPG

Thank you for your thoughts, I will investigate this further as it's a great move, smooth out my landings!!

Cheers Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi all

Managed to do a little more today between gardening and wood chopping or rather chainsawing it.We start early as we need a fair bit to get through winter. So best to make a start now. The local mill delivers big bundles of slab wood for a really good price, but it means a fair bit of hard grafting to get it done.

Worked or the pull pull for the rudder this afternoon, the rudder has a brass post which hooks up internally so it has to be addressed now before I can cover the fuselage. 

20230928_170412.thumb.jpg.72177b562dc45d41e2ae539e7aa48e89.jpg.b06ded22efaf22c4abd054b5d6a18060.jpg

 

I have set up a metal steering arm and it was going to be retained on the rudder post with a grub screw, but I quickly realized that was not going to be a good idea.

So I drilled the both sides of the steering arm and also the brass tubing  I made use of the existing thread in the steering arm to screw a bolt right through and will have a nut to secure it with added loctite.

20240207_192852.thumb.jpg.9cfca55a0e93446cbfbeb9ef3443af97.jpg

I am planning on using turnbuckles in the cable between the servo and the rudder to help wih tensioning the lines.I have 2 sizes to choose from. 

20240207_192924.thumb.jpg.c6e518f4bfac1c2dbc887e0ca2fd9778.jpg

 

20240207_192919.thumb.jpg.0de527168c990e6d5ddbfc2f9ed7c244.jpg

I just wanted to thank everyone for all the valued input provided, this is the largest build I have ever undertaken, so Thanks !for your comments 

Cheers Steve NZ 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Steve,

One thing to watch, the clevises pins can be  a point of failure when used on a metal horn. I've seen a number of 1/3rd scale WW1 models meet an untimely  end due to this. I would either drill out and  replace the pin with a steel bolt or use clevises that are already designed this way. 

 

Also the steel turnbuckles will be more robust than the brass ones.

Edited by 2.4g Shaun
Typo
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, 2.4g Shaun said:

Hi Steve,

One thing to watch, the clevises pins can be  a point of failure when used on a metal horn. I've seen a number of 1/3rd scale WW1 models meet an untimely  end due to this. I would either drill out and  replace the pin with a steel bolt or use clevises that are already designed this way. 

 

Also the steel turnbuckles will be more robust than the brass ones.

Hi thanks, yes ,I will action that ,t You are right I had Clevis pin break several months ago!! Thank you 

Edited by Steve Fox
Add more discussion
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, FlyinFlynn said:

Check the formed thread in the clevis is a good fit to the turnbuckle, then lock it up with a locknut. It will prevent the thread wearing should there be any rattling between the turnbuckle and the clevis.

Thank you very much for the tip,it's these little things that make the difference in doing a good job  cheers Steve NZ 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...